Third Quarter 2012 Update!
I initiated a position in Great-West
Lifeco. Generally I am enthused by the low valuation, paying 0.9x to 1.0x book
value for expected ROEs of 11% to 12%, make the lifecos cheap. Positively,
Great-West is above Canadian lifeco peers given lower expected earnings
volatility and higher expected ROE (16.3% in 2013) and is less exposed to
movements in equity markets and interest rates than its lifeco peers.
and Industrial Alliance . Those potential
impacts dwarf the impact of sales or near-term management actions on earnings
and capital, and as such we continue to expect moves in interest rates and
equities to be the primary drivers of share prices. The near-term overweight/underweight
call comes down to individual investors’ views on equity markets and interest
rates.
On the other hand Great-West remains less exposed
to movements in equity markets and long-term interest rates than its peers.
Great-West’s sensitivity to equity market movements is lower and mostly
fee-driven. The decline in bond yields since Q3/12 began, is also not as
potentially negative for Great-West’s near-term net income outlook as it would
be for its peers. We are less concerned about movements in macro
factors—particularly interest rates and equity markets—having a
major impact on our earnings estimates for Great-West. The lower exposure to
interest rate movements is driven by tighter asset/liability duration
management, which has kept the company less exposed to longer duration
products. The lower exposure to movements in equity markets is a reflection of
the company having introduced GMWB variable annuities later than peers and
therefore being exposed to a much more conservative segregated fund/variable
annuity portfolio.
Great-West has a more
highly rated investment portfolio than its peers but more exposed to Europe,
given the company’s business mix, although the majority of that exposure is in
the UK .
Isolating the peripheral European countries, exposure to banks and other
financial institutions’ bonds (Ireland ,
Italy , and Spain ) is 0.4%
of invested assets. Additionally, approximately 0.2% of the company’s invested
assets are in bonds issued by the Governments of Portugal, Ireland , Italy ,
and Spain .
The company has no exposure left to the Greek Government or Greek banks, and no
exposure to Portuguese banks.